This page is an English translation of the Korean original. If there is any discrepancy, the Korean version prevails.

Congenital malformation syndromes predominantly involving facial appearance주로 얼굴형태에 영향을 주는 선천기형증후군

Contents and key points
ItemDetails
A. Classification codesICD-10: Q87.0 | Special Copayment Reduction: V185 | Re-certification cycle: 5 years | Primary name: Congenital malformation syndromes predominantly involving facial appearance
B. SynonymsGorlin-Chaudhry-Moss syndrome, cryptophthalmos syndrome, Goldenhar syndrome, Robin syndrome, acrocephalopolysyndactyly, acrocephalosyndactyly, cyclopia, Möbius syndrome, oral-facial-digital syndrome, whistling face, Carpenter syndrome, oculodentodigital dysplasia
C. Adult onsetLikelihood of first onset in adulthood: very low — almost all syndromes included in Q87.0 are diagnosed at birth or in the neonatal period, but swallowing disorders and strabismus in Möbius syndrome, airway complications in Robin syndrome, cardiac complications in Carpenter syndrome, and the like require management in adulthood as well.
1. HistoryFirst describers and naming history of each syndrome — Goldenhar (1952), Robin (1923), Möbius (1888), Carpenter (1909), etc.
2. CausesHeterogeneity of causes by syndrome — gene mutations (OTX2, RAB23, MKS1, etc.), vascular disruption, environmental factors, multifactorial, etc.
3. GeneticsInheritance patterns by syndrome — varied: autosomal dominant/recessive, X-linked, aneuploidy, new mutations, etc.
4. General epidemiologyBirth prevalence of each syndrome — Goldenhar about 1/5,000, Robin 1/8,500, Möbius 1/50,000~500,000, etc.
5. PathophysiologySyndrome-specific mechanisms such as impaired neural crest cell migration, defects in cranial nerve development, premature fusion of craniofacial sutures, and abnormal mesodermal segmentation.
6. SymptomsCharacteristic symptoms by syndrome, such as facial asymmetry, cleft lip and palate, micrognathia, microphthalmia/cyclopia, facial paralysis, limb malformations, and heart defects.
7. SignsPhysical examination findings — auricular malformations, hemifacial microsomia, ptosis, corneal opacity, hypotonia, bifid uvula, etc.
8. ScreeningPrenatal ultrasound, fetal MRI, cfDNA, fetoscopy. Neonatal clinical screening — assessment of airway, feeding, and cardiac function.
9. DiagnosisMultidisciplinary approach including clinical criteria, craniofacial radiography, molecular genetics (panel/exome), brain MRI, and ophthalmologic, hearing, and cardiac examinations.
10. TreatmentCraniofacial plastic surgery, airway management (tongue traction, tracheostomy), cleft palate surgery, ophthalmologic surgery, communication therapy, cardiac corrective surgery, etc.
11. PrognosisVaries greatly by syndrome and associated malformations — poor prognosis in cyclopia, relatively good in isolated Robin syndrome, intelligence generally normal in Möbius and Goldenhar.
12. PreventionGenetic counseling, prenatal diagnosis, PGT, avoidance of exposure to teratogenic drugs such as misoprostol during pregnancy. Multidisciplinary follow-up care.
13. ReferencesGorlin RJ et al. 2001; Logeart-Avramoglou D et al.; Benko S et al. Nat Genet 2009 … and 7 others

1. History

Goldenhar Syndrome

Goldenhar syndrome (hemifacial microsomia, oculo-auriculo-vertebral spectrum, OAV spectrum) was named in 1952 when the Belgian ophthalmologist Maurice Goldenhar first systematically described cases of facial asymmetry accompanied by epibulbar dermoids, preauricular appendages, and preauricular fistulae. However, similar clinical findings had already been mentioned sporadically in the ophthalmologic records of Carl von Arlt in 1845 and in Lind's report in 1881. In 1963, Gorlin et al. expanded the clinical spectrum to include vertebral anomalies, and subsequently the comprehensive term oculo-auriculo-vertebral spectrum, which also includes craniofacial anomalies, heart defects, and central nervous system anomalies, came into general use.

Robin Sequence

Robin syndrome (Pierre Robin sequence) began to be known in 1923 when the French dentist Pierre Robin described the triad of micrognathia, glossoptosis, and airway obstruction. Robin initially included cleft palate as an essential element, but later studies confirmed that the same triad can appear without cleft palate, so cleft palate is now regarded as an optional element. Modern medicine distinguishes isolated occurrence from occurrence with other syndromes (syndromic), and it has been established that Robin syndrome can accompany Stickler syndrome, 22q11 deletion, Nager syndrome, and others.

Möbius Syndrome

Möbius syndrome was named in 1888 when the German neurologist Paul Julius Möbius reported cases of congenital bilateral facial paralysis with abducens palsy. Before Möbius, similar cases were reported individually by Graefe in 1880, Harlan in 1879, and others, but the systematic description was made by Möbius. In the late 20th century, epidemiologic studies published intensively in Brazil showing that misoprostol exposure in early pregnancy is associated with Möbius syndrome marked a new turning point in etiologic research.

Carpenter Syndrome

Carpenter syndrome originated in 1909 when the British physician George Carpenter reported cases of two siblings with craniofacial malformations and limb anomalies. In 1966, Neuhauser et al. reported additional cases, and it was classified as acrocephalopolysyndactyly type II. In 2010, Pearce et al. discovered biallelic loss-of-function mutations in the RAB23 gene, first identifying the molecular basis of Carpenter syndrome.

Other historical syndromes

Gorlin-Chaudhry-Moss syndrome is a rare syndrome named in 1960 when Gorlin, Chaudhry, and Moss reported cases of two girls with coronal craniosynostosis, hypophthalmos, and skin and dental anomalies. Cryptophthalmos syndrome, that is, Fraser syndrome, was systematized in 1962 when Gordon Fraser described cases with cryptophthalmos, syndactyly, and cleft palate. Cyclopia (synophthalmia) has such a long history of description that its name derives from the Cyclops of ancient mythology, and its etiologic association with holoprosencephaly was established in the 20th century. Oral-facial-digital syndrome was described in 1954 by Papandreou and independently, and X-linked dominant inheritance has been confirmed.


2. Causes

Causes of Goldenhar syndrome

The causes of Goldenhar syndrome (OAV spectrum) are heterogeneous and not yet fully identified. Most cases occur sporadically, but some show familial occurrence. Proposed causes include (1) impaired blood supply during formation of the first pharyngeal arch in early pregnancy, particularly disruption of the stapedial artery, (2) impaired migration, proliferation, and differentiation of neural crest cells, and (3) environmental factors such as maternal diabetes, smoking in early pregnancy, and exposure to vasoconstrictors. In genetic studies, variants of OTX2 (forebrain and eye development), HOXA1 (brainstem and ear development), BAPX1 (NKX3-2), GSC, MYT1, and others have been reported in some familial cases, but they do not converge on a single causative gene.

Causes of Robin syndrome

Robin syndrome is understood through the concept of a sequence. That is, the mechanical cascade hypothesis is supported: the primary defect, micrognathia, prevents the normal descent of the tongue at 9–11 weeks of fetal life, impeding palatal fusion and resulting in a U-shaped cleft palate. Causes of micrognathia include intrauterine compression (oligohydramnios, multiple pregnancy, uterine malformations), abnormal neuromuscular development (hyoid muscles, digastric muscle), and genetic factors acting in combination. When an associated syndrome is present, the genetic cause of that syndrome (COL2A1/COL11A1/COL11A2 in Stickler syndrome, 22q11.2 deletion, etc.) is directly involved.

Causes of Möbius syndrome

Möbius syndrome results from agenesis or hypoplasia of the facial nerve nucleus (VII) and abducens nerve nucleus (VI). Proposed etiologies are (1) the vascular disruption hypothesis: impaired brainstem blood flow (basilar artery territory) at 4–8 weeks of development, (2) misoprostol exposure: Brazilian epidemiological data showing that misoprostol use for abortion in early pregnancy increases the risk of Möbius syndrome about 30-fold (Gonzalez et al., 1993; Pastuszak et al., 1998), and (3) genetic factors: HOXA1, PLXND1, and REV3L variants have been reported in some familial cases. A multifactorial origin is supported.

Causes of Carpenter syndrome

Carpenter syndrome is an autosomal recessive genetic disorder, and biallelic loss-of-function mutations in the RAB23 (chromosome 6p11-p12) gene are identified in most cases. RAB23 is a negative regulator of the Hedgehog signaling pathway and plays an important role in cranial suture and limb development. In some RAB23-negative Carpenter syndrome patients, MEGF8 (15q21) gene variants have been identified as an alternative genetic cause, so genetic heterogeneity exists.

Causes of other syndromes

Cyclopia is associated with alobar holoprosencephaly, a failure of midline separation of the forebrain (prosencephalon), and is caused by variants in genes such as SHH, ZIC2, SIX3, and TGIF1, trisomy 13, and trisomy 18. Oral-facial-digital syndrome (OFD syndrome type I) is X-linked dominant, caused by variants in the OFD1 (CXORF5) gene, and is lethal in males. Acrocephalosyndactyly (Apert syndrome) is known to be caused by FGFR2 (p.S252W, p.P253R) variants, cryptophthalmos syndrome (Fraser syndrome) by FRAS1, FREM2, and GRIP1 variants, and whistling face syndrome (Freeman-Sheldon syndrome) by MYH3 variants.


3. Genetics

Overview of inheritance patterns by syndrome

The syndromes included in Q87.0 have very diverse inheritance patterns and cannot be explained by a single genetic model. Genetic information for the main syndromes is summarized below.

SyndromeMode of inheritanceMain genes/chromosomesDe novo mutation rate
Goldenhar syndrome (OAV)Mostly sporadic; some AD, AROTX2, HOXA1, GSC, BAPX1High (~most)
Robin syndrome (isolated)Multifactorial/sporadic17q24.3 (SOX9 regulation), 2q24Variable
Möbius syndromeMostly sporadic; rarely ADPLXND1, REV3L, HOXA1High
Carpenter syndromeAutosomal recessive (AR)RAB23(6p11-p12), MEGF8Low
Acrocephalosyndactyly (Apert)Autosomal dominant (AD)FGFR2(10q26)Very high (>98%)
Cyclopia/holoprosencephalyAD, AR, chromosomal abnormalitiesSHH, ZIC2, SIX3; 13T, 18TVariable
OFD syndrome IX-linked dominantOFD1(Xp22.2)Moderate
Fraser syndromeAutosomal recessive (AR)FRAS1(4q21), FREM2(13q13)Low
Freeman-SheldonAD (mostly de novo)MYH3(17p13)High
Gorlin-Chaudhry-MossPresumed autosomal recessiveUnidentified-

Genetics of acrocephalosyndactyly (Apert syndrome)

Acrocephalosyndactyly (Apert syndrome) is caused by gain-of-function mutations in the FGFR2 (fibroblast growth factor receptor 2) gene. In about 99% of all cases, one of two variants, p.Ser252Trp (about 66%) or p.Pro253Arg (about 33%), is found. FGFR2 is located on the long arm of chromosome 10 (10q26.13), and variants in the linker region at the Ig-loop II–III junction cause nonspecific broadening of FGF ligand binding, leading to premature fusion of cranial sutures and abnormalities of limb chondrocytes. The de novo mutation rate of Apert syndrome is very high, over 98%, and shows a positive correlation with advanced paternal age. The p.Ser252Trp variant carries a relatively higher risk of intellectual disability, and the p.Pro253Arg variant tends to have relatively more severe syndactyly, but there is much phenotypic overlap.

Genetic heterogeneity of Robin syndrome

The isolated form of Robin syndrome is associated with copy number variants (CNV) or point mutations in the long-range regulatory region (17q24.3) of the SOX9 gene on chromosome 17. SOX9 is a transcription factor essential for cartilage and jaw development, and microdeletions in this gene's regulatory region are proposed as the mechanism causing micrognathia. In addition, KCNJ2 gene variants (a gene associated with Andersen-Tawil syndrome) are also associated with some cases of Robin syndrome, and variants in the region of the long arm of chromosome 2 (2q24) have also been reported. In Stickler syndrome–associated Robin syndrome, collagen gene variants such as COL2A1 (12q13.11) are the primary cause.


4. General epidemiology

Birth prevalence of each syndrome

The syndromes grouped under the Q87.0 code differ greatly in birth prevalence. Goldenhar syndrome (OAV spectrum) is reported in about 1 in 3,500–5,600 births, making it relatively common in this group. The sex ratio is about 3:2 male to female, with male predominance. Robin syndrome occurs in 1 in 8,500 births; 35–40% are isolated, 40–50% are associated with syndromes, and the rest are unclassified. Möbius syndrome is estimated at 1 in 50,000–500,000 births, very rare, with insufficient accurate epidemiological data. Carpenter syndrome is an ultra-rare disease reported in only a few dozen families worldwide; the exact birth prevalence is unknown but is estimated at about 1–5 per fewer than 1 million births.

Acrocephalosyndactyly (Apert syndrome) occurs in 1 in 65,000–88,000 births and is relatively common among FGFR2-related craniosynostoses. Cyclopia is reported in about 1 in 40,000–100,000 births, but because of frequent spontaneous abortion, the actual incidence after conception is estimated to be much higher. Oral-facial-digital syndrome type I (OFD I) occurs in about 1 in 50,000–250,000 births; because it is X-linked dominant and lethal in males, surviving cases are reported practically only in females. Fraser syndrome (cryptophthalmos syndrome) occurs in 1 in 200,000 births, is very rare, and has high infant mortality.

Epidemiology in Korea

In Korea, these syndromes are classified under Special Copayment Reduction V185 (rare disease) and are registered and managed separately. According to rare disease statistics from the Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service (HIRA), the number of patients registered in Korea in the Q87.0 code group is several hundred per year, and diagnosis and treatment take place mainly at specialist craniofacial centers (Asan Medical Center, Seoul National University Hospital, Yonsei University Severance Hospital, etc.). Goldenhar syndrome also accounts for a considerable proportion of congenital craniofacial anomalies in Korea, and new cases are continually identified in neonatal intensive care units and craniofacial clinics. Möbius syndrome is often diagnosed in a setting of collaboration between pediatric neurology and ophthalmology.


5. Pathophysiology

Impaired neural crest cell migration — Goldenhar syndrome, OFD syndrome

Most craniofacial structures derive from neural crest cells (NCC). NCC originate from the dorsal ectoderm of the neural tube at 3–4 weeks of development and migrate to the first and second pharyngeal arches, forming the facial skeleton, ossicles, ear cartilage, skin dermis, dental mesenchyme, and more. In Goldenhar syndrome (OAV spectrum), impaired migration or survival of NCC is proposed to occur during formation of the first and second pharyngeal arches (4–8 weeks of gestation). The vascular disruption hypothesis, in which local ischemia due to abnormal development of the stapedial artery causes NCC death, is supported. Experimentally, an OAV-like phenotype is induced in mice by administering vasoconstrictors in early pregnancy.

Mechanisms of premature cranial suture fusion — Carpenter syndrome, acrocephalosyndactyly

In acrocephalosyndactyly (Apert syndrome), FGFR2 gain-of-function variants cause ligand-independent dimerization of the receptor or an abnormal increase in ligand-binding affinity. In sutural cells of the cranial sutures, FGFR2 overactivation prematurely promotes osteoblast differentiation through ERK, PLCγ, and STAT signaling and reduces apoptosis of sutural fibroblasts, causing premature ossification of the coronal suture. In Carpenter syndrome, RAB23 deficiency causes overactivation of the Hedgehog signaling pathway, which simultaneously explains abnormal differentiation of cranial sutural cells and limb chondrocytes. RAB23 is involved in membrane recycling of the Ptch1 protein, and with RAB23 deficiency, inhibition of Smo is released and Gli transcription factors become overactivated.

Defects in cranial nerve nucleus development — Möbius syndrome

The core lesion of Möbius syndrome is agenesis or hypoplasia of the brainstem facial nerve nucleus (cranial nerve VII nucleus, facial motor nucleus) and abducens nerve nucleus (cranial nerve VI nucleus). These nuclei form at 4–8 weeks of development from rhombomeres r4, r5, and r6 of the rhombencephalon. According to the vascular disruption hypothesis, transient ischemia of the basilar artery or vertebral artery branches in early pregnancy causes selective damage to brainstem nuclei. Misoprostol can reduce brainstem blood flow through hemodynamic changes from uterine contractions or through direct vasoconstriction. In genetic models, PLXND1 encodes a semaphorin receptor involved in cranial nerve development, and loss of this gene causes abnormal positioning and projection of motor nuclei.

Abnormal mesodermal segmentation — Robin syndrome

Micrognathia, the primary cause of Robin syndrome, results from impaired mesodermal growth of the mandibular first pharyngeal arch. Abnormalities in the long-range regulatory region of the SOX9 gene impair formation of Meckel's cartilage, leading to mandibular underdevelopment. Around 11 weeks of fetal life, the tongue should move out of the palatal fusion space within the oral cavity, but with micrognathia the tongue becomes lodged in the oral cavity (glossoptosis), physically obstructing horizontal movement and fusion of the palatal shelves. This chain reaction is described as the mechanism causing a U-shaped cleft palate. Intrauterine positional deformation (breech presentation, oligohydramnios) is interpreted as contributing to its development by applying external compression to the mandible.

Pathogenesis of cyclopia

Cyclopia is the most severe form of alobar holoprosencephaly, in which a single eye or incomplete fusion of two eyes occurs in the midline. The pathogenesis is associated with failure of SHH (Sonic Hedgehog) signaling to separate the forebrain midline. SHH is secreted early in development from the notochord and prechordal plate and induces separation of the forebrain midline. Reduced SHH signaling (SHH gene variants, ZIC2 variants, etc.) or exogenous inhibition by SHH inhibitors such as cyclopamine causes failure of forebrain separation and fusion of the eyes. Abnormalities of the intracellular SHH pathway are also presumed in trisomy 13.


6. Symptoms

Symptoms of Goldenhar syndrome (OAV spectrum)

The clinical symptoms of Goldenhar syndrome can be broadly divided into ocular, ear-auditory, oromaxillofacial, and spinal and other systems. Ocular abnormalities include epibulbar dermoid (the most characteristic finding, 55–60%), corneal dermoid, coloboma, microphthalmia, ptosis, and strabismus. Ear abnormalities include preauricular tags and preauricular pits observed in 80–90%, accompanied by microtia, external auditory canal atresia, and conductive hearing loss. Facial asymmetry appears as hemifacial microsomia, characterized by unilateral hypoplasia of the mandible, zygomatic arch, and temporal bone. Oral abnormalities may include cleft lip and palate, macrostomia, and oral dermoids. Cervical spine abnormalities (especially C2–C3 fusion, Klippel-Feil anomaly), cardiac malformations (VSD, ASD, TOF), and renal malformations additionally occur.

Symptoms of Robin syndrome

The core triad of Robin syndrome is (1) micrognathia: in the neonatal period, the mandible is markedly small and retruded, giving a 'bird face' appearance in profile; (2) glossoptosis: a relatively large tongue falls back and obstructs the airway; and (3) cleft palate: a U-shaped or V-shaped soft palate defect is present in about 80%. The most serious clinical problem is upper airway obstruction in the neonatal period, causing hypoxemia, apnea, feeding difficulties, and failure to thrive. Depending on the associated syndrome, symptoms of Stickler syndrome (ocular abnormalities, joint hypermobility, sensorineural hearing loss) or the cardiac malformations and immune abnormalities of 22q11 deletion syndrome are added.

Symptoms of Möbius syndrome

The core symptoms of Möbius syndrome are congenital bilateral facial palsy (VII) and abducens palsy (VI). Facial palsy makes facial expression impossible, causing severe impairment of social communication. In the neonatal period, poor suck, feeding difficulties, and impaired control of oral secretions are the main problems. Esotropia and impaired lateral eye movement due to abducens palsy are present. Limb abnormalities (Poland anomaly, clubfoot, syndactyly, limb deficiencies) accompany about 30–50%. Developmental delay is reported in about 10–15%, but most have normal cognitive function. There are reports that the rate of associated autism spectrum disorder is higher than in the general population (about 30–40%).

Symptoms of Carpenter syndrome

Carpenter syndrome is a form of acrocephalopolysyndactyly and includes (1) craniosynostosis: premature fusion of multiple sutures causing various abnormal skull shapes such as acrocephaly, turricephaly, and trigonocephaly; (2) syndactyly/brachydactyly: soft-tissue syndactyly of the toes is particularly common, accompanied by brachydactyly and polydactyly of the hands; (3) obesity: obesity develops from childhood in most patients; (4) hypogonadism; (5) congenital heart malformations (VSD, ASD, PS); and (6) intellectual disability (mild to moderate). Facial findings include a flat nose, low-set ears, entropion, and superficial corneal opacity.

Symptoms of oral-facial-digital syndrome (OFD I)

The triad of OFD I is oral, facial, and digital abnormalities. Oral abnormalities: lobes and clefts of the tongue, multiple frenulae, dental abnormalities, cleft palate. Facial abnormalities: hypertelorism, nasal malformations, craniofacial asymmetry. Digital abnormalities: syndactyly, brachydactyly, polydactyly. In females, polycystic kidney disease accompanies about 50–70%, affecting long-term renal function. Some have cerebellar abnormalities (resembling Dandy-Walker malformation).

Symptoms of cyclopia and other syndromes

Cyclopia presents with a single midline eye or a fusion of two eyes accompanied by absence of the nose (arhinia) or a nasal malformation (proboscis), with severe cerebral malformations due to alobar holoprosencephaly. The prognosis is extremely poor, and almost all die within the neonatal period. Whistling face syndrome (Freeman-Sheldon syndrome) is characterized by marked limitation of mouth opening, lip protrusion in a whistling posture, microstomia, and contractures of the hands and feet (camptodactyly, clubfoot). Cryptophthalmos syndrome (Fraser syndrome) is accompanied by cryptophthalmos, in which the eyelids are completely covered by skin, syndactyly, laryngeal and airway malformations, renal agenesis, and more, and has low survival.


7. Signs

Physical examination findings in Goldenhar syndrome

The characteristic findings of Goldenhar syndrome on physical examination are, first, epibulbar dermoid: observed as a yellowish-white triangular nodule at the conjunctival-corneal border, causing reduced vision when the cornea is involved. Second, preauricular tags and pits: skin-colored projections or depressions in front of the tragus, easily seen with the naked eye. Third, facial asymmetry: unilateral facial flattening, with unilateral hypoplasia of the soft and bony tissues of the mandibular ramus, zygomatic arch, and temporal region. Fourth, microtia and external auditory canal stenosis/atresia: reduced ear size and narrowing of the external auditory canal are observed. Fifth, macrostomia: excessive lateral extension of the mouth corner. Sixth, cervical spine abnormalities in the neck (unilateral neck muscle hypoplasia, torticollis) may be identified by palpation and inspection.

Physical examination findings in Möbius syndrome

Patients with Möbius syndrome characteristically have a masklike face on physical examination. There are no facial expression movements such as smiling or frowning, and tear secretion is normal. Because of abducens palsy, the eyes are fixed in the midline or adducted position, and horizontal eye movements are impossible. Even with facial palsy, vertical eye movements (upward and downward gaze) are generally preserved. Absence of Bell's phenomenon can make corneal exposure during sleep a problem. Oral examination reveals reduced movement of the palate, soft palate, and pharynx and limited tongue movement, and dysarthria is prominent. Limb examination may show Poland anomaly (pectoral muscle deficiency + ipsilateral hand anomalies), clubfoot, and syndactyly.

Physical examination findings in Carpenter syndrome

Cranial examination in Carpenter syndrome reveals various forms of skull deformity. With turricephaly or acrocephaly, the anteroposterior diameter of the skull is relatively long, and the frontoparietal region is pointed upward. Sutural ridging may be palpable. Facial examination shows a flat nasal bridge, hypertelorism or hypotelorism, low-set ears, and epicanthal folds. On hand examination, brachydactyly and syndactyly (between the 2nd and 3rd digits) are characteristic. On foot examination, polydactyly (especially accessory digits of the medial toes) and soft-tissue syndactyly are identified. On abdominal examination, an umbilical hernia may be present. If a heart murmur is heard on cardiac auscultation, a congenital heart malformation (VSD, PS) is suspected.

Physical examination findings in Robin syndrome

The most urgent finding on newborn examination in Robin syndrome is signs of upper airway obstruction. In the supine position, airway obstruction on inspiration is marked, with abdominal breathing and sternal retractions observed. Improvement in airway patency can be observed when the position is changed to lateral decubitus or prone. Oral examination reveals narrowing of the floor of the mouth due to micrognathia and posterior displacement of the tongue. A U-shaped hard and soft palate defect is confirmed with a mirror or oral speculum. Inspiratory stridor may be heard on auscultation. To distinguish associated syndromes, a full-body examination including the eyes (myopia, retinal detachment, cataract), joints (hypermobility), ears (sensorineural hearing loss), and cardiac auscultation is essential.

Physical examination findings in acrocephalosyndactyly (Apert syndrome)

Cranial examination in Apert syndrome reveals acrobrachycephaly due to premature fusion of the coronal sutures. The forehead is flat or retruded, the vertex is abnormally high, and the shape is tower-like. Facial examination shows midface hypoplasia and characteristic proptosis. Palatal examination reveals a high-arched palate or abnormal palatine ridges. On hand examination, complete complex syndactyly of three or more fingers is characteristic, observed as a 'mitten hand' or 'glove hand' pattern.


8. Screening

Prenatal ultrasound screening

Suspicious findings in many Q87.0 syndromes can be detected by prenatal ultrasound. Abnormal skull shape appears on detailed ultrasound at 18–20 weeks of gestation as acrocephaly, brachycephaly, or asymmetric skull shape. Micrognathia is quantified on profile views by the facial profile index (FPI), which measures mandibular retrusion, or by the jaw-to-neck distance. A mandibular length below standard ultrasound reference values is a suspicious finding for Robin syndrome, Treacher Collins syndrome, and others. Goldenhar syndrome is suspected from facial asymmetry, ear malformations (microtia), and cervical spine abnormalities, but ultrasound sensitivity is limited. Cyclopia is clearly visible on ultrasound from early on (14–16 weeks) as a single midline orbit, absent nose, and forebrain abnormalities. Syndactyly (Apert, Carpenter) is identified as non-separation of the fingers and toes.

Fetal MRI

When an abnormality is suspected on prenatal ultrasound, fetal MRI is used for detailed evaluation of the central nervous system, craniofacial structures, and airway. When Robin syndrome is suspected, the degree of airway narrowing, tongue position, and extent of the palatal defect are confirmed by MRI to prepare the delivery plan and neonatal management. In holoprosencephaly and cyclopia, fetal brain MRI is decisive for anatomical classification and prognostic assessment. In Carpenter syndrome, it is useful for evaluating the extent of cranial suture abnormalities and the state of brain development.

Molecular genetic prenatal testing

When there is a family history or abnormal ultrasound findings, fetal DNA is obtained by chorionic villus sampling (CVS, 10–13 weeks of gestation) or amniocentesis (15–18 weeks of gestation) to test for causative genes. For acrocephalosyndactyly (Apert), the specific FGFR2 variants (p.S252W, p.P253R) are checked first. For Carpenter syndrome, RAB23 and MEGF8 panel testing is performed. Cyclopia with autosomal abnormalities (trisomy 13, trisomy 18) can be rapidly confirmed by FISH or QF-PCR. Chromosomal microarray (CMA) detects a broad range of structural variants including microdeletions and microduplications and is used for molecular diagnosis of many syndromes.

Newborn clinical screening

When craniofacial anomalies are identified immediately after birth, systematic multisystem screening is performed. Airway assessment: continuous oxygen saturation monitoring, observation of breathing patterns during feeding, and confirmation of airway anatomy by flexible nasopharyngoscopy if needed. Hearing screening: newborn hearing screening (ABR, OAE). Screening for cardiac malformations: pulse oximetry, dual blood pressure measurement, echocardiography. Ophthalmological screening: fundus examination, check for corneal opacity. Esophageal and gastrointestinal abnormalities: imaging when gastrointestinal malformations are present. This multisystem screening determines priorities for neonatal intensive care and is the basis for forming a multidisciplinary team.


9. Diagnosis

Clinical diagnostic criteria

Established clinical diagnostic criteria differ for each Q87.0 subsyndrome. Goldenhar syndrome (OAV spectrum) is diagnosed according to international diagnostic criteria (ICVAS, 2014) when abnormalities are present in at least two of the three axes—ocular, ear, and facial—or when there is a family history involving two or more categories. Robin syndrome is diagnosed clinically by the combination of micrognathia + glossoptosis (with or without cleft palate), and differentiation of associated syndromes is essential. Möbius syndrome, according to the 2007 Möbius syndrome consensus diagnostic criteria, requires both congenital bilateral facial palsy (VII) and abducens palsy (VI), and other neuromuscular diseases (mitochondrial myopathy, myotonic dystrophy, etc.) must be excluded. Carpenter syndrome is clinically suspected from the combination of craniosynostosis + syndactyly/polydactyly + obesity/hypogonadism and diagnosed by confirmation of the RAB23 gene.

Radiological and imaging diagnosis

Radiological evaluation of craniofacial syndromes includes the following. Plain skull radiographs: premature suture fusion (loss of suture lines, copper-beaten appearance), identification of sutural ridging. 3D CT: detailed evaluation of cranial suture status, orbital volume, degree of midface protrusion, and airway anatomy. An essential preoperative test in Carpenter and Apert syndromes. Brain MRI: evaluates signs of increased intracranial pressure (ventricular dilation, cerebellar tonsillar descent), corpus callosum abnormalities, septo-optic dysplasia, and more. Skeletal survey: identifies limb malformations (syndactyly, polydactyly, brachydactyly), spinal abnormalities (OAV spectrum), and rib abnormalities. Panoramic X-ray: evaluates abnormal dental and jaw development.

Molecular genetic diagnosis

After clinical and radiological evaluation, molecular genetic testing is performed for confirmation. Targeted gene panel: a craniofacial malformation gene panel (including FGFR1/2/3, TWIST1, EFNB1, RAB23, MEGF8, OFD1, etc.) is the first choice when clinical suspicion is high. Whole-exome sequencing (WES): used when the targeted panel is negative or to identify the cause of nonspecific craniofacial malformations. Chromosomal microarray (CMA): essential for distinguishing chromosomal causes such as 22q11.2 and 1p36 by detecting microdeletions and duplications. Single-gene Sanger sequencing: used to confirm specific variants and for carrier testing within families. Variant interpretation applies pathogenic/likely pathogenic classification according to ACMG/AMP criteria.

Multidisciplinary specialist testing

A multidisciplinary approach is essential for complete diagnostic evaluation of patients with craniofacial malformations. Ophthalmological examination: evaluation of visual acuity, fundus, refractive errors, intraocular pressure, and extraocular muscle movements. In Goldenhar syndrome, evaluation of corneal dermoid size and corneal involvement; in Möbius syndrome, evaluation of corneal exposure risk. Hearing tests: auditory brainstem response (ABR), otoacoustic emissions (OAE), pure-tone audiometry (older children). In cases with microtia, detailed temporal bone CT evaluation. Cardiac testing: echocardiography. Neurocognitive assessment: developmental screening tools (Bayley, DDST), intelligence tests (WISC, Stanford-Binet). Speech and feeding assessment: feeding assessment by a speech-language pathologist, videofluoroscopic swallowing study (VFSS). Sleep studies: quantitative evaluation of obstructive sleep apnea by polysomnography in cases with airway narrowing.


10. Treatment

Airway management — Robin syndrome

In neonatal treatment of Robin syndrome, securing the airway is the top priority. In mild airway obstruction, oxygen saturation often improves with prone positioning alone (step 1 treatment). For moderate airway obstruction not resolved by prone positioning, insertion of a nasopharyngeal airway (NPA) is effective (step 2). As surgical treatment, tongue-lip adhesion (TLA) has traditionally been used, securing the airway by suturing the tongue to the lower lip. Recently, bilateral mandibular distraction osteogenesis (MDO) has attracted attention as an effective alternative. MDO achieves long-term airway patency by gradually lengthening the mandible and fundamentally enlarging the airway space. Tracheostomy is performed as a last resort when the above methods fail or when there are serious comorbidities.

Craniofacial plastic surgery — Carpenter and Apert syndromes

Surgical correction of craniosynostosis is essential to prevent increased intracranial pressure and proptosis and to improve skull shape. Strip craniectomy is a minimally invasive approach performed at 3–6 months of age, but must be combined with helmet therapy. Cranial vault remodeling is a more extensive approach performed at 6–12 months of age. In Apert syndrome, fronto-orbital advancement and Le Fort III osteotomy are applied to correct midface hypoplasia. Syndactyly separation surgery is performed in stages within 6–18 months of age to secure hand function, and toe syndactyly has lower priority because its functional impact is small.

Cleft palate surgery

Cleft palate can accompany most Q87.0 syndromes, and the standard timing of surgery for speech development is 9–18 months of age. Two-flap palatoplasty (Wardill-Kilner or von Langenbeck) or Furlow palatoplasty is mainly used. In Robin syndrome, airway problems must be resolved before cleft palate surgery, and in some cases palatal surgery is delayed to secure the airway. Intensive pre- and postoperative therapy by a speech-language pathologist is essential.

Ophthalmological treatment

Surgical excision of epibulbar dermoids in Goldenhar syndrome is recommended when they affect visual development. In Möbius syndrome, ocular lubricants (artificial tears), nighttime eyelid taping, and lateral tarsorrhaphy if needed are used to prevent exposure keratitis. Strabismus surgery is important both functionally and cosmetically, and medial rectus recession is the standard surgery for abducens palsy in Möbius syndrome.

Rehabilitation and multidisciplinary management

In patients with Möbius syndrome, occupational therapy and speech and feeding therapy are provided intensively from the neonatal period. For limitations in social communication due to facial palsy, psychological support and social skills training are provided. As reconstructive microsurgery, dynamic facial reanimation using gracilis free muscle transfer may be considered in adolescence. Obesity and hypogonadism in Carpenter syndrome require long-term management by an endocrinologist. In all syndromes, when hearing abnormalities are identified, hearing aids or bone-anchored hearing aids (BAHA) are applied early. When developmental delay is present, language, cognitive, and gross and fine motor development are supported through an early intervention program.


11. Prognosis

Prognosis of Goldenhar syndrome

The prognosis of patients with Goldenhar syndrome differs greatly depending on the type and severity of associated malformations. Regarding intellectual function, mild or greater intellectual disability accompanies about 10–15%, but most have normal intelligence. Regarding hearing, conductive hearing loss due to microtia and external auditory canal atresia is common, and early application of hearing aids or bone conduction hearing aids and support for language development determine the prognosis. Vision depends on the degree of corneal involvement by epibulbar dermoids and whether amblyopia develops, and early surgery and refractive correction improve the visual prognosis. When cardiac and renal malformations are present, complications of those organ systems affect the long-term prognosis. Overall, life expectancy in isolated Goldenhar syndrome without serious malformations is close to normal.

Prognosis of Robin syndrome

The prognosis of isolated Robin syndrome (isolated Pierre Robin sequence) is relatively good. If the neonatal airway crisis is appropriately managed, in about 80–85% of patients the mandible undergoes catch-up growth with age and micrognathia improves spontaneously. Accordingly, glossoptosis and airway obstruction also gradually improve, and airway-related problems resolve in most cases before age 5–7. Speech development after cleft palate surgery generally improves to within the normal range when combined with intensive speech therapy. However, when an associated syndrome is present (Stickler syndrome, 22q11 deletion, etc.), additional complications of that syndrome (progressive myopia, immune abnormalities, cardiac malformations, joint problems, etc.) affect the long-term prognosis.

Prognosis of Möbius syndrome

Life expectancy in Möbius syndrome is close to normal in the absence of serious associated malformations. The most important long-term complication is social functional impairment; permanent limitation of facial expression poses ongoing challenges to social interaction, self-esteem, and psychological adjustment. Dynamic facial reanimation (gracilis muscle transfer) can partially restore smiling in some patients and contributes to an improved psychological prognosis. When autism spectrum disorder is present, the prognosis for social functioning and independent living is further limited. Corneal exposure complications can be prevented with ongoing ophthalmological care. Cognitive function is normal in most, and normal academic achievement is possible with appropriate educational support.

Prognosis of Carpenter syndrome

The prognosis of Carpenter syndrome is determined by management of intracranial pressure, correction of cardiac malformations, and the severity of intellectual disability. If increased intracranial pressure due to craniosynostosis is not adequately treated, optic nerve damage (blindness), worsening developmental delay, and chronic headaches occur. Congenital heart malformations are mostly managed by surgical correction. Intellectual disability is often in the mild to moderate range, and early educational intervention improves the prognosis. Endocrine management of obesity and hypogonadism is important for quality of life in adulthood. Long-term survival is possible, but the capacity for independent living varies greatly among patients.

Prognosis of cyclopia and alobar holoprosencephaly

Alobar holoprosencephaly with cyclopia has an extremely poor prognosis. Most cases die in the neonatal period or early infancy, and even survivors have severe neurological impairment, epilepsy, and endocrine abnormalities (central diabetes insipidus, growth hormone deficiency). Parents should receive thorough counseling on options for palliative care and intensive supportive care.


12. Prevention

Genetic counseling and estimation of recurrence risk

Parents of a child with a Q87.0 syndrome must receive genetic counseling from a clinical genetics specialist before any future pregnancy. The recurrence risk differs by syndrome. Carpenter syndrome (RAB23, AR) carries a 25% recurrence risk when both parents are carriers. Because Apert syndrome is mostly due to de novo mutations, the parents' recurrence risk is low (except for germline mosaicism), but an affected parent carries a 50% risk. OFD I (X-linked dominant) carries a 50% risk for daughters of affected mothers and is lethal in boys, so sex selection is important for preventing recurrence. Goldenhar syndrome and Möbius syndrome are mostly sporadic, with an empirical recurrence risk at the general population level, but when a rare familial variant is identified, the risk according to that inheritance pattern applies.

Preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) and prenatal diagnosis

In families with an identified causative gene variant, preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) is effective in preventing recurrence. PGT is a method of testing embryos obtained by in vitro fertilization (IVF) for the variant and selectively transferring normal embryos. It is the ideal method for AR or AD syndromes with a known causative variant. Prenatal diagnosis (CVS or amniocentesis) is a method of determining whether the fetus is affected after pregnancy is established, and if the variant is positive, it supports the parents' autonomous decision on whether to continue the pregnancy. Non-directive genetic counseling should precede prenatal diagnosis.

Avoiding environmental risk factors

With regard to Möbius syndrome, exposure to misoprostol in early pregnancy (4–12 weeks) must be strictly avoided. Epidemiological evidence has established that misoprostol use for illegal drug-induced abortion in Brazil and elsewhere increases the incidence of Möbius syndrome several dozen-fold. Exposure in early pregnancy to vasoconstrictors (ergotamine derivatives, etc.), reported as possibly associated with the occurrence of Goldenhar syndrome, should also be avoided. Infections in early pregnancy (especially first-trimester rubella), excessive alcohol consumption, and poor glycemic control of diabetes should also be managed as risk factors for craniofacial malformations. Because advanced paternal age increases the risk of de novo mutations, counseling on this is also provided.

Early multidisciplinary intervention and long-term follow-up

In preventive management of Q87.0 syndromes, early multidisciplinary intervention is the key strategy for minimizing complications. A multidisciplinary team approach at a specialist craniofacial center involving plastic surgery, neurosurgery, ophthalmology, otolaryngology, dentistry (orthodontics, oral and maxillofacial surgery), audiology, speech-language pathology, pediatric neurology, cardiology, and developmental pediatrics is recommended. Intracranial pressure, vision, hearing, cognitive development, the status of cleft palate repair, and airway status are systematically monitored through regular follow-up examinations. At each recertification cycle (5 years), functional status and treatment needs are reassessed and Special Copayment Reduction is renewed. Linking patients and families with support groups is important for psychosocial adjustment, and information on the Korean rare disease helpline and related patient organizations is provided.


13. References

  1. Gorlin RJ, Cohen MM Jr, Hennekam RCM. Syndromes of the Head and Neck. 4th ed. Oxford University Press; 2001. (ISBN: 978-0195118612) — the classic reference for the Q87.0 subsyndromes.
  2. Teber OA, Gillessen-Kaesbach G, Fischer S, et al. Genotyping in 46 patients with tentative diagnosis of Treacher Collins syndrome revealed unexpected phenotypic variation. Eur J Hum Genet. 2004;12(11):879-890. DOI: 10.1038/sj.ejhg.5201262
  3. Benko S, Fantes JA, Amiel J, et al. Highly conserved non-coding elements on either side of SOX9 associated with Pierre Robin sequence. Nat Genet. 2009;41(3):359-364. PMID: 19234473
  4. Pastuszak AL, Schuler L, Speck-Martins CE, et al. Use of misoprostol during pregnancy and Möbius' syndrome in infants. N Engl J Med. 1998;338(26):1881-1885. PMID: 9637806
  5. Jenkins D, Baynam G, De Catte L, et al. Carpenter syndrome: extended RAB23 mutation spectrum and analysis of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay. Hum Mutat. 2011;32(4):E2069-E2078. PMID: 21504509
  6. Wilkie AOM, Bochukova EG, Hansen RM, et al. Clinical dividends from the molecular dissection of craniosynostosis. Am J Med Genet C Semin Med Genet. 2007;145C(3):229-243. PMID: 17640042
  7. Kaye CI; American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Genetics. Introduction to the newborn screening fact sheets. Pediatrics. 2006;118(3):1304-1312. PMID: 16951025
  8. Hartsfield JK Jr. Review of the etiologic heterogeneity of the oculo-auriculo-vertebral spectrum (Hemifacial Microsomia). Orthod Craniofac Res. 2007;10(3):121-128. PMID: 17651151
  9. Verzijl HT, van der Zwaag B, Cruysberg JR, Padberg GW. Möbius syndrome redefined: a syndrome of rhombencephalic maldevelopment. Neurology. 2003;61(3):327-333. PMID: 12913192
  10. Vargel I, Ugar DA, Taner S, Canten MK. Distraction osteogenesis for hypoplastic mandibles in Pierre Robin sequence: comparison of the long-term results of primary mandibular distraction osteogenesis versus tongue-lip adhesion and palatoplasty. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2012;129(3):675-687. PMID: 22373968