This page is an English translation of the Korean original. If there is any discrepancy, the Korean version prevails.

Osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate Juvenile Osteochondrosis of Hand (Kienböck Disease, Juvenile)

A.Classification codesICD-10 M92.2 | Special Copayment Reduction V299
B.SynonymsOsteochondrosis of the carpal lunate (juvenile)〔Kienböck〕
C.Adult onsetLow — typically onset in adolescence, and first presentation in adults is rare. The adult-onset form is classified separately as M93.1 (Kienböck disease).
1.HistoryDescribed by Kienböck (1910); process of establishing the classification into juvenile and adult forms.
2.CausesVulnerable blood supply of the carpal lunate (lunate bone) + repeated trauma and compression.
3.GeneticsNo clear single genetic cause; associated with anatomical variation (ulnar variance).
4.General epidemiologyRare osteochondrosis of the adolescent growth period; male predominance; dominant hand involved.
5.PathophysiologyIschemic necrosis of the lunate → revascularization → remodeling (success/failure).
6.SymptomsWrist pain, swelling and limited motion; gradual worsening.
7.SignsDorsal wrist tenderness; abnormal lunate signal on X-ray and MRI.
8.ScreeningX-ray + MRI in adolescents with recurrent wrist pain.
9.DiagnosisMRI (bone marrow edema, extent of necrosis); X-ray staging (Lichtman); CT for bone structure.
10.TreatmentBy stage: immobilization, decompression, vascularized bone graft, arthroplasty; similar to the adult form.
11.PrognosisThe juvenile form has a higher chance of spontaneous healing than the adult form; good with early treatment.
12.PreventionAvoidance of repeated wrist overload; early diagnosis.
13.ReferencesList of key references and guidelines

1. History

Osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate (lunate) was first systematically reported in 1910 when the Austrian radiologist Robert Kienböck (1871–1953) described increased density and collapse of the lunate on X-rays of patients with wrist pain and functional impairment. Kienböck interpreted this finding as avascular necrosis of the lunate, and the disease was later named Kienböck disease after him. The ICD-10 classification distinguishes, by age of onset, the adolescent-onset form as M92.2 (osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate [juvenile]) and the adult-onset form as M93.1 (Kienböck disease of adults).

The juvenile form occurs during the childhood and adolescent growth period, in which the lunate, with open growth plates, sustains ischemic injury and undergoes necrosis and remodeling. In the 1960s–1970s, Arrol and Lichtman established staging classifications, providing a basis for treatment guidelines. Advances in imaging technology, especially the introduction of MRI, made it possible to assess bone marrow edema, the degree of vascularization and the extent of necrosis, refining early diagnosis and stage-specific treatment selection. Juvenile Kienböck disease differs somewhat in clinical approach in that it has greater potential for spontaneous remodeling than the adult form, and related long-term studies are ongoing.

2. Causes

Osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate is understood to result from the combined effects of a vulnerable blood supply to the lunate and repeated mechanical loading. The lunate is one of the bones with an anatomically limited blood supply, and cases with a single-vessel vascular supply account for about 7–26% of the total. When this vascular vulnerability is present, repeated wrist loading, trauma or occupational or sports-related overuse injury causes microfractures and compression, leading to vascular injury.

Negative ulnar variance, an anatomical variation (in which the ulnar head is shorter than the radius), is known to increase the load concentrated on the lunate and raise the risk of Kienböck disease. However, negative ulnar variance alone is not sufficient, and a combination with vascular anatomical vulnerability is needed for onset. In the juvenile form, vulnerability is presumed to arise during periods when the blood supply cannot keep up with rapid bone growth during the growth period.

3. Genetics

No specific single-gene mutation has been identified in juvenile osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate. However, some studies have reported familial clustering, so the possibility of a genetic predisposition has not been completely ruled out. There may be genetic factors affecting ulnar variance or anatomical variation of the lunate vascular structure, but there have been no large genomic studies to date.

Just as genetic predisposition has not been completely ruled out for osteochondroses in general, there is a hypothesis that, in Kienböck disease as well, genetic variants involved in connective tissue, vascular development and bone growth may explain differences in individual susceptibility. In addition, an association with coagulation disorders (e.g., protein C deficiency, prothrombin variants) has been raised in some small studies, but there is no definitive conclusion. At present, it is not classified as a single-gene disorder that would be an indication for genetic counseling.

4. General epidemiology

Juvenile osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate is a rare disease, and accurate prevalence and incidence statistics are limited. The juvenile form accounts for a minority of all Kienböck disease (juvenile + adult forms), and most clinical studies involve adult patients. The juvenile form mainly occurs in adolescents aged 8–15 and is reported slightly more often in boys. The wrist of the dominant hand is usually involved.

The risk may be higher with repeated heavy use of the wrist in occupational or sports activities. Clustering has been reported in occupational groups such as gymnasts, typists and carpenters, but epidemiologic data limited to the juvenile form are lacking. It is reported in both Asian and Western populations, and differences in prevalence between races have not been clearly established.

5. Pathophysiology

The pathogenesis of osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate can be summarized as avascular necrosis followed by remodeling. The first stage is injury to the lunate blood supply: vascular compression or injury due to single-vessel supply anatomy or repeated microtrauma causes bone marrow ischemia. When ischemia persists, hematopoietic marrow cells undergo necrosis, followed by loss of osteocytes. On MRI, it initially appears as bone marrow edema with low T1 and high T2 signal, and with progression it changes to necrosis with low signal on both T1 and T2.

In the revascularization stage, new capillaries penetrate the necrotic tissue, osteoclasts resorb the necrotic bone and osteoblasts form new bone. In the juvenile form, thanks to the high remodeling potential of growing bone, this revascularization and remodeling can be more successful than in the adult form. However, if remodeling fails, the lunate gradually collapses, leading to degenerative changes of the entire wrist joint (carpal collapse). The Lichtman staging classification (Stage I–IV) reflects the degree of progression of this process.

6. Symptoms

The main symptom of juvenile osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate is wrist pain, usually starting as a deep dull ache on the dorsal aspect of the wrist that worsens with activity and is somewhat relieved by rest. Early on there is only mild pain and discomfort, so diagnosis is often delayed. As the disease progresses, wrist swelling, reduced grip strength and limited range of wrist flexion and extension appear, interfering with schoolwork, sports and daily activities. In severe cases, stiffness of the entire wrist joint may develop.

Symptoms often progress gradually over weeks to months, and sometimes worsen abruptly after a specific traumatic event. In the early stage, plain X-rays may appear normal, so the diagnosis is easily missed without MRI. Because juvenile patients may describe pain less clearly than adults, careful history-taking and physical examination by the clinician are important.

7. Signs

On physical examination, tenderness over the lunate (the central dorsal wrist, just ulnar to the long extensor tendon) is the most characteristic sign. Wrist joint swelling may be observed, and dynamometer measurement can confirm reduced grip strength compared with the unaffected side. Measurement of active and passive wrist range of motion (ROM) shows limited flexion and extension.

Plain X-rays initially appear normal or show only a mild increase in lunate density, and with progression flattening, fragmentation and collapse of the lunate are observed. MRI is the most sensitive imaging tool and can visualize bone marrow edema and the extent of necrosis earliest and most accurately. The characteristics of MRI and CT findings differ by Lichtman stage, and using all of these images for staging is recommended.

8. Screening

Suspecting osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate in adolescent patients complaining of recurrent wrist pain is the starting point for early detection. At the first visit, plain X-rays (wrist AP and lateral) are taken to check for abnormalities in the density and shape of the lunate. Even if X-rays are normal, MRI is performed to confirm early bone marrow edema when clinical suspicion is strong. Assessing negative ulnar variance by measuring ulnar variance (zero reference line method) also provides a diagnostic clue.

In terms of screening, it is important to include this disease in the differential list when wrist pain persists in adolescent athletes or adolescents in occupational activities who overuse the wrist. Careful follow-up is also needed when there is a family history of this disease. A bone scan can be used as an adjunct when MRI is unavailable, but because of its low specificity it is generally not recommended.

9. Diagnosis

The diagnosis of osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate is made by integrating clinical findings, plain X-rays and MRI. The Lichtman staging classification (1977, later revised) is the most widely used imaging staging system. Stage I: normal X-ray, MRI signal abnormality only; Stage II: increased density on X-ray, shape preserved; Stage IIIa: lunate collapse, carpal alignment preserved; Stage IIIb: lunate collapse + abnormal rotation of the scaphoid; Stage IV: accompanied by pancarpal degenerative arthritis. The juvenile form uses the same staging classification as the adult form, and it is a key criterion in deciding treatment policy.

MRI is most sensitive for assessing early bone marrow edema and the degree of vascularization (gadolinium enhancement). CT is useful for assessing bony structural details (bone fragmentation, microfracture patterns). The differential diagnosis includes triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) injury, carpal instability, lunate fracture, osteomyelitis and bone tumors.

10. Treatment

The treatment policy is determined by stage and the patient's age (stage of growth). In the juvenile form, especially in early stages (Stage I–II), spontaneous healing is sometimes possible with conservative treatment such as splinting or cast immobilization and activity restriction alone. This is an important difference from adult Kienböck disease. The duration of conservative treatment is several months to 1 year, during which the course is monitored with MRI and X-rays.

When there is no response to conservative treatment or stage progression is confirmed, surgical intervention is considered. When negative ulnar variance is present, ulnar lengthening or radial shortening osteotomy redistributes the load on the lunate. Vascularized bone graft, lunate decompression, intercarpal fusion and others are applied according to stage. In Stage IV with severe pain, proximal row carpectomy or total wrist fusion is performed as a salvage procedure.

11. Prognosis

The prognosis of juvenile osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate is generally better than that of adult Kienböck disease. Because the potential for revascularization and remodeling is great when onset occurs during the growth period, cases have been reported in which the lunate recovers to a near-normal shape with early diagnosis and appropriate unloading. However, if lunate collapse progresses due to delayed diagnosis or inappropriate treatment, it leads to carpal degenerative arthritis and worsens the long-term functional prognosis.

In long-term follow-up (10–20 years) studies after treatment, many patients treated at early stages (Stage I–II) maintain acceptable wrist function and pain control. However, at Stage IIIb or above, recovery of wrist function is limited even after surgery, and chronic pain and reduced grip strength often remain. Whether patients return to work or sports varies greatly by stage and treatment method.

12. Prevention

There is currently no established primary prevention for osteochondrosis of the carpal lunate. However, recognizing risk factors and having an early detection system in place is best. In adolescent athletes who overuse the wrist repetitively (gymnastics, tennis, etc.), it is desirable to prevent overuse injury through appropriate adjustment of training volume, rest and use of wrist braces. Adolescents whose wrist pain persists for 2 weeks or longer should promptly receive specialist evaluation to secure the opportunity for early detection.

Once diagnosed, minimizing mechanical load on the lunate during treatment and restricting wrist-loading activities until remodeling is confirmed are key to preventing stage progression. Even after treatment, it is important to confirm revascularization and structural stability with regular follow-up imaging and to respond quickly to abnormal findings.

13. References

  1. Lichtman DM, Lesley NE, Simmons SP. The classification and treatment of Kienböck's disease: the state of the art and a look at the future. J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 2010;35(7):549-554. doi:10.1177/1753193410374690
  2. Goldfarb CA, Hsu J, Gelberman RH, et al. The Lichtman classification for Kienböck's disease: an assessment of reliability. J Hand Surg Am. 2003;28(1):74-80. PMID: 12563644
  3. Irisarri C. Aetiology of Kienböck's disease. J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 2004;29(3):281-287. doi:10.1016/S0363-5023(03)00485-1
  4. Lutsky K, Beredjiklian PK. Kienböck disease. J Hand Surg Am. 2012;37(9):1942-1952. doi:10.1016/j.jhsa.2012.06.029
  5. Allan CH, Joshi A, Lichtman DM. Kienböck's disease: diagnosis and treatment. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2001;9(2):128-136. PMID: 11281635
  6. Beredjiklian PK. Kienböck's disease. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2009;91(12):2988-3002. doi:10.2106/JBJS.I.00434
  7. D'Agostino P, Saliou G, Laribi MA, et al. Ulnar variance and Kienböck's disease in children and adolescents. Chir Main. 2012;31(1):26-31. doi:10.1016/j.main.2011.12.005
  8. Gelberman RH, Salamon PB, Jurist JM, Posch JL. Ulnar variance in Kienböck's disease. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1975;57(5):674-676. PMID: 1150704
  9. Watanabe A, Souza F, Vezeridis PS, et al. Ulnar-sided wrist pain. II. Clinical imaging and treatment. Skeletal Radiol. 2010;39(9):837-857. doi:10.1007/s00256-010-0963-7
  10. Schmitt R, Froehner S, Coblenz G, Christopoulos G. Kienböck disease. Eur J Radiol. 1997;25(3):180-189. PMID: 9374155